Pie in the Sky
Looking for a spot where you can enjoy delicious food in a cozy, inviting atmosphere? Pie in the Sky in Lancaster, PA, might just be the perfect place for you. Located at 105 Duncan St, Ste C, this restaurant offers a unique dining experience that's hard to beat. Whether you're craving a savory pie, a sweet treat, or a casual meal with friends, Pie in the Sky has something to satisfy every taste.
This hidden gem specializes in freshly baked pies, but don’t be fooled – it’s not just about dessert! The menu is diverse, featuring a variety of savory pies that are perfect for lunch or dinner. From hearty chicken pot pies to flavorful vegetarian options, each dish is crafted with care and packed with comforting flavors. If you're a fan of sweet pies, you won't be disappointed either. Their fruit-filled pies, with perfectly flaky crusts and rich fillings, are simply irresistible.
One of the things that make Pie in the Sky stand out is its inviting, laid-back atmosphere. The space feels like a home away from home, where you can relax and enjoy your meal in peace. Whether you're dining solo or with family and friends, it’s a place where everyone feels welcome.
Not only does Pie in the Sky focus on great food, but they also prioritize top-notch service. The staff is friendly, attentive, and always ready to offer recommendations if you're unsure about what to order. It's this kind of personal touch that makes the dining experience here so enjoyable.
So, next time you’re in Lancaster and craving something comforting and delicious, make sure to check out Pie in the Sky. With its wide selection of savory and sweet pies, friendly service, and inviting atmosphere, it’s no wonder this restaurant has become a local favorite.
Reviews
Love these guys! Always glad to see you, always on time with your order! The subs are fresh and stuffed with fresh meats and cheese and clean crisp veggies! Special orders don't upset them, always helpful with suggestions! Watching them all work together to get the job done is a true joy! Bravo PITS!
When we visit our family in Lancaster, PA for the weekend we always require them to get takeout from Pie in the Sky at least once while we are there. The food is so comforting and always consistently prepared. We have never had a bad takeout experience. Our favorites are the chicken cheesesteak, buffalo chicken cheese steak, tuna sub, pepperoni and sausage pizza, lasagna and baked ziti. The lasagna and baked ziti are huge portions and so good. Very cheesy and we love the sauce. The bread and side salad are also very nice to make a complete meal. The sweet peppers and the fresh tomatoes on the salad have a good flavor profile. Food is always well packaged and well made. Service is always friendly and efficient. Sometimes it may take a few repeat calls to get through to place your order but then you know that you are ordering from a popular place. It is great to be able to support such a nice small business that has consistently good Italian food at a great price point. That is why we always make sure we stop by when we are in the area. Highly recommend.
Being a New Yorker you appreciate a good Pizza. I also love there subs and calzones (Stromboli )
One of the best Pizza in town. Friendly staff. Good food.
The best pizza in lancaster Everything is excellent! The staff is friendly,treat you like family. Service is fast. It's my local pizza and sandwich shop-