Stepping into Pie in the Sky is like entering a flavorful wonderland for comfort food lovers. The pizza selection alone is a journey—starting with the classic Round Neapolitan Thin Crust Cheese Pizza, perfectly crisp with a delicate balance of sauce and cheese. For something more indulgent, the Special Pizza adds layers of flavor that make it an instant favorite. Prefer a thicker bite? Their Sicilian Square Thick Crust pizzas, available in both Cheese and Special styles, deliver a deep-dish satisfaction that's nothing short of comforting.
The Gourmet Pizza lineup is where creativity shines. The White Pizza is creamy and rich, while the BBQ Chicken Pizza hits all the smoky, savory notes. The Buffalo Chicken and Vegetarian options round out the list with bold spice and garden-fresh ingredients. Craving Sicilian-style? The same gourmet flavors are reimagined on a thick crust base—equally indulgent and satisfying.
For lighter fare, the salads go beyond the basics. The Grilled Chicken Salad is a protein-packed favorite, while the Antipasto and Chef Salads are colorful, hearty meals on their own.
Sides like Broccoli Cheese Bites and Bacon Cheese Fries are guilty pleasures worth every bite, especially when paired with Chicken Nuggets, Spicy Wings, or Buffalo Chicken Strips—crispy, saucy, and oh-so-satisfying.
Strombolis and Calzones bring gooey, oven-baked goodness—whether you opt for Steak, Ham & Cheese, or a loaded Special Stromboli. Subs and wraps, both hot and cold, cater to every craving: from the classic Italian Cold Cut to the bold Cheesesteak Hoagie Wrap.
And don’t skip the dinners. The Beef Lasagna, Stuffed Shells, and Cheese Ravioli are bubbling, cheesy comfort food classics that taste homemade.
Pie in the Sky isn’t just a pizzeria—it’s a full-on flavor fest.